Sign up to stay up to date on the Middletown Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
26 Pittsford Way 4 3.1 N/A $1,200,000 Unknown 0 days
1213 Clinton Ln 2 2 N/A $469,000 Unknown 0 days
274 E Passaic Ave 3 2 N/A $549,900 Unknown 0 days
445 Morris Ave 2 1 N/A $319,000 Unknown 0 days
315 East St 4 2.1 N/A $599,000 Unknown 0 days
14 Maplewood Dr 5 3 N/A $1,399,000 Unknown 0 days
51 High St 5 3.1 N/A $1,050,000 Unknown 0 days
200 Wychwood Rd 4 3.2 N/A $1,399,000 Unknown 0 days
33 S Mountain Rd 4 4 N/A $1,895,000 Unknown 0 days
22 Midvale Dr 4 3.1 N/A $1,449,000 Unknown 0 days
64 Conover Ave 3 1 1,224 $539,000 $440 0 days
18 Metro Vista Dr 4 3.1 2,685 $950,000 $353 0 days
15 Lake Rd 4 2.1 N/A $775,000 Unknown 0 days
2 Hobson Drive 6 6.1 7,500 $3,300,000 $440 0 days
740 Hillside Ave 5 3 N/A $799,000 Unknown 0 days
46 Kearney St 4 3.1 2,943 $649,000 $220 1 day
161 Willowdale Ave 3 2.1 N/A $695,000 Unknown 0 days
78 Rocktown Rd N/A N/A N/A $3,000,000 Unknown 0 days
34 Sunnyslope Ave 5 2.1 2,908 $1,149,000 $395 0 days
25 S Shore Rd 4 2 N/A $625,000 Unknown 0 days
67 Woodland Rd N/A N/A N/A $369,000 Unknown 4 days
57 Robbins Ave 4 2.1 N/A $899,000 Unknown 0 days
6 Clover Court 3 2.1 N/A $769,000 Unknown 0 days
51 High St 5 3.1 N/A $1,050,000 Unknown 0 days
175 Wertsville Rd 5 3.1 1,957 $360,000 $183 0 days
88 Lawrence Ave 4 1.1 N/A $699,000 Unknown 0 days
84 Tiffany Pl 8 4 N/A $989,999 Unknown 0 days
4 Wilbur Ter 2 1 N/A $545,000 Unknown 0 days
138 Irving Ave 7 6.1 N/A $1,825,000 Unknown 0 days
25 Stanley Ct 3 1 N/A $499,900 Unknown 0 days
16 Trinity Pl 5 4.1 N/A $1,895,000 Unknown 0 days
9 Northfield Ct 3 1.1 N/A $589,000 Unknown 0 days
113 Main St N/A N/A N/A $1,850 Unknown 0 days
15 Crescent Ridge Rd 4 2.1 2,865 $1,125,000 $392 0 days
16 Joanne Dr 2 1.1 N/A $535,000 Unknown 0 days
73 Riggs Pl 3 3 N/A $849,000 Unknown 0 days
35 Wadsworth Dr 3 2.1 2,558 $955,599 $373 0 days
18 Stewart Pl 2 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 0 days
39 Oberlin St 5 2.1 N/A $1,050,000 Unknown 0 days
327 North Ave E 4 3 N/A $799,900 Unknown 0 days
327 North Ave E N/A N/A N/A $799,900 Unknown 0 days
185 S Morris St N/A N/A N/A $750,000 Unknown 2 days
102 Kingsberry Dr 2 2.1 1,648 $495,000 $300 1 day
714 North Ave West 3 1 N/A $660,000 Unknown 0 days
106 Virginia St 3 2 N/A $785,000 Unknown 0 days
8 Woodland Dr 5 3 N/A $735,000 Unknown 0 days
589 Madison Dr 2 2 N/A $435,000 Unknown 0 days
49 Raynor Rd 4 2.1 2,550 $929,000 $364 0 days
366 Broad St 3 2 N/A $459,000 Unknown 0 days
490 Route 46 N/A N/A N/A $650,000 Unknown 0 days
Average: 3.5 2.5 4,050 $820,166 $350 91 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 4101
Viewing 1 - 50 of 4101
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
718 Buckland Ct 2 2.1 N/A $500,000 Unknown 0 days
905 Victoria Ct 2 2.1 1,401 $390,000 $278 0 days
921 Robin Rd 2 1.1 1,472 $375,000 $254 0 days
22 Carol Dr 3 2 N/A $539,000 Unknown 0 days
22 Thomas Ter 4 2.1 N/A $799,900 Unknown 0 days
440 Prospect Ave 3 2 N/A $499,999 Unknown 0 days
14 Tunnell Rd 4 2.1 2,220 $695,000 $313 0 days
15 SANDALWOOD DRIVE 5 3.1 5,000 $1,400,000 $280 0 days
225 Seymour Rd 4 1.1 N/A $500,000 Unknown 0 days
56 WILL LANE 6 6.2 N/A $2,299,000 Unknown 0 days
34 Milton Ave 3 2 N/A $675,000 Unknown 0 days
97 Commonwealth Ave 4 3.1 3,480 $1,550,000 $445 0 days
26 Cornell Way 4 3.1 N/A $1,450,000 Unknown 0 days
305 Michaels Ct 2 2.1 N/A $398,000 Unknown 1 day
82 Fischer Ave 3 1.1 N/A $749,900 Unknown 0 days
2623 Frederick Ter 3 2.1 1,776 $699,000 $393 0 days
41 Buffalo Hollow Rd 4 3.1 1,811 $629,000 $347 0 days
38 Brookside Ter 5 4.2 N/A $2,699,900 Unknown 0 days
28 Raven Dr 3 2.1 N/A $825,000 Unknown 0 days
22 Ditmars Cir 4 2.1 N/A $679,999 Unknown 0 days
25 Tansboro Rd 2 2 N/A $349,000 Unknown 0 days
6 Estler Ln 4 2 N/A $829,900 Unknown 0 days
211 Conway Ct 3 2.1 N/A $1,195,000 Unknown 0 days
10 Klimback Ct 4 2.1 2,442 $799,000 $327 0 days
2 Sweet Briar Ct 5 3 3,070 $1,375,999 $448 0 days
10 Cambray Rd 5 3.1 N/A $1,088,000 Unknown 0 days
32 New St 3 2.1 N/A $649,000 Unknown 0 days
16 West Rd 6 5.1 N/A $3,150,000 Unknown 0 days
76 Spring St 5 3 N/A $1,290,000 Unknown 0 days
205 Green St 3 1.1 N/A $500,000 Unknown 0 days
1248 Schmidt Ave 4 3 N/A $649,000 Unknown 0 days
1 Carey Ct 3 2.1 N/A $849,999 Unknown 0 days
17 Quail Brook Court 2 2.1 1,464 $550,000 $375 1 day
11 White Bridge Rd 4 3.2 N/A $950,000 Unknown 0 days
95 Sliker Rd 4 2 N/A $639,000 Unknown 0 days
9 Lee Rd 3 2.1 N/A $799,900 Unknown 0 days
211 Marcella Rd 3 2 N/A $570,000 Unknown 0 days
41 Dexter Dr N 2 2.1 N/A $849,000 Unknown 0 days
52 Channing Dr 3 1.1 N/A $499,000 Unknown 0 days
55 N Shore Rd 4 3.2 N/A $1,150,000 Unknown 0 days
47 Grove St 3 1 1,204 $485,000 $402 0 days
37 Spring Garden Dr 3 2.1 N/A $975,000 Unknown 1 day
193 Walnut St 4 3 N/A $975,000 Unknown 1 day
10 Ames Road 2 3.1 N/A $895,000 Unknown 1 day
126 Hickson Dr 6 4.1 N/A $1,799,000 Unknown 1 day
26 Mount Arlington Rd 3 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 1 day
20 Berkley St 3 3 N/A $610,000 Unknown 5 days
200 Crestwood Dr 5 4.2 5,334 $2,280,000 $427 1 day
990 Croton Rd 3 1.1 N/A $545,000 Unknown 1 day
3 Woodlawn Ter 3 1.1 N/A $689,000 Unknown 1 day
Average: 3.5 2.4 2,563 $902,614 $389 2 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 155
Viewing 1 - 50 of 155
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
260 Prospect St 2 2 N/A $619,000 $619,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
235 Elmwood Ave N/A N/A N/A $1,295,000 $1,250,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
125 Mountainview Rd 4 2.1 N/A $944,888 $900,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
2094 Westfield Road Cir 3 3 N/A $775,000 $851,500 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
94 Drake Ln 2 2 N/A $374,900 $375,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
67 Fox Hill Rd 3 2 N/A $649,900 $720,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
19 Andover Dr 3 2.1 N/A $769,000 $813,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
10 Sunnyfield Dr 4 2.1 N/A $739,000 $870,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
143 Sapphire Ln 2 2 N/A $344,900 $347,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
68 Overlook Dr 1 1 N/A $269,900 $260,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
7 Park Ave 3 1 N/A $374,900 $415,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
100 Mountain Ave 4 2 N/A $699,999 $800,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
55 Heritage Ct 3 2.1 N/A $639,000 $647,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
83 Terra Cotta Rd 3 1 N/A $339,900 $335,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
44 Rumana Rd 2 1 N/A $550,000 $613,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
7 Timber Dr 4 2.1 N/A $899,000 $992,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
7 Stone Mountain Ct 4 3.1 N/A $1,170,000 $1,145,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
55 Scarlet Oak Dr 3 2.1 N/A $670,000 $665,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
379 Victoria Dr 3 3 N/A $595,000 $585,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
23 Rock Creek Woods Dr 3 2.1 N/A $729,000 $710,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
24 Water St 4 3.1 N/A $1,350,000 $1,425,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
6 Saw Mill Rd 3 2.2 N/A $749,900 $785,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
113 Stanley Ct 4 2 N/A $639,000 $600,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
28 Verkade Dr 5 4 N/A $975,000 $1,100,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
6 Wadsworth Dr 3 2.1 N/A $799,990 $769,990 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
375 Rifle Camp Rd 1 1 N/A $289,900 $290,000 Unknown Unknown 9/16/26
2401 Hudson St 3 2 N/A $525,000 $430,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
187 Grove St 3 1.1 N/A $875,000 $875,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
5 Harvey Dr 5 3.1 N/A $900,000 $880,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
10 Smith Manor Blvd 1 1 N/A $250,000 $295,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
403 Sharp St 3 2 N/A $400,000 $420,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
109 Tuscan Rd 4 2.2 N/A $975,000 $1,384,575 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
4 James Ct 3 1.1 N/A $550,000 $585,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
70 Bromley Pl 3 2 N/A $529,900 $650,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
32 Hamilton Rd 2 1 N/A $495,000 $550,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
6 Proprietor Ln 5 3.1 N/A $1,299,000 $1,343,250 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
20 Juniper Ct 4 3.1 N/A $1,260,000 $1,400,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
13 Hunters Trl 4 3.1 N/A $1,399,000 $1,360,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
24 Harvard St 3 1.1 N/A $519,900 $550,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
14 High Ridge Rd 4 2.1 N/A $700,000 $780,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
13 Sunset Dr 4 2 N/A $675,000 $690,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
4 Muirhead Ct 4 3.1 N/A $998,000 $1,038,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
903 Springhouse Dr 2 2.1 N/A $484,000 $495,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
33 Edgar St 3 2 N/A $979,000 $999,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
238 Sutphin Ln 3 2.1 N/A $740,000 $740,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
45 Magnolia Ave 4 2 N/A $799,000 $825,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
201 Little Falls Rd 3 2.1 N/A $749,000 $750,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
7 New St 3 2 N/A $259,000 $260,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
28 Warwick Cir 3 3 N/A $699,999 $750,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
707 Gallows Hill Rd 3 1.1 N/A $699,000 $665,000 Unknown Unknown 9/15/26
Average: 3.5 2.3 0 $838,338 $882,246 $0 N/A day
Viewing 1 - 50 of 9152
Viewing 1 - 50 of 9152

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated: