Middletown Real Estate Search

Middletown Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Middletown real estate search for homes, condo, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Middletown Properties for Sale

Curious about what’s happening in the Middletown real estate market? Sign up for a  Middletown Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Middletown Properties for Sale

$1,949,000
5 Beds 5.1 Baths 4053367 MLS
Designed for living. Meticulously rebuilt and expanded from the studs up, this exceptional Madison home offers 4 finished levels, 5 bedrooms and 5.1 baths, ideally situated on a picturesque street just moments from vibrant downtown, award-winning schools, parks, boutique shopping, acclaimed restaurants and direct NYC trains. The stunning chef's kitchen features JennAir appliances, 6-burner range, quartz countertops, custom Fabuwood cabinetry and a large center island, opening to the family room with gas fireplace. Beautiful 4" white oak floors flow throughout. A paver patio with gas line for grilling extends the living space outdoors. A formal dining room, living room, private office and powder room complete the first floor.Upstairs are 4 bedrooms, including a luxurious primary suite with heated bath floors, custom walk-in closet and 2 generous reach-in closets. Two bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bath, plus an additional bedroom, hall bath and laundry. The finished third floor offers a private 5th bedroom and full bath. The finished lower level features a recreation room, full bath and storage.Thoughtfully rebuilt for today's lifestyle, nearly every component is new, including Hardie Plank siding, prairie-style windows, roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, insulation, landscaping, water/sewer lines and irrigation. A detached 1-car garage completes this beautifully reimagined Madison home. This home is still an active construction site. Completion estimated in Dec 2026.

36 Highland Ave, Madison Boro

$799,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 4053362 MLS
RARE FANWOOD OPPORTUNITY. Beautiful home with exceptional potential. An OVERSIZED lot and endless possibilities begin with the land. Welcome to 374 South Ave., a rare opportunity to own one of the area's most distinctive residential properties, set on a beautifully manicured site measuring 202x98x212x64 (approx. 19,800 ft.), close to downtown & transportation. This meticulously maintained stone Cape Cod offers the perfect combination of timeless charm, move-in-ready comfort, & exciting future possibilities for a homeowner, builder, or investor. Whether you envision expanding the existing home into your dream residence, or creating a spectacular outdoor living space, the opportunities are worth exploring. This inviting home features 4 BR & 2 full baths with a flexible floor plan. 2 BRs on the 1st floor & 2 additional bedrooms upstairs. Inside, you will appreciate HW floors, a stone wood-burning fireplace, attic storage, a one-car attached garage, & a full basement with high ceilings for future living space. Properties offering this rare combination of a well-maintained home, substantial land, & potential for future development seldom become available. Whether you're searching for your forever home, an investment opportunity, or your next building project 374 South Ave. deserves your attention. Buyer is responsible for conducting their own due diligence regarding zoning requirements, variances, and municipal approvals.

374 South Ave, Fanwood Boro

$1,350,000
4 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053354 MLS
Backing onto the golf course and set on approximately three-quarters of an acre on professionally done landscaping, this Cherry Valley home offers a standout setting and plenty of room both inside and out. A new composite deck takes full advantage of the fairway views, while a newer roof adds peace of mind. Access to the deck can be either through the double sliding glass doors from the eat-in kitchen or from the mudroom and laundry. Hardwood floors extend through much of the spacious and bright interior on both levels. Formal living and dining rooms flank the entry foyer and a two-story family room features a wood burning fireplace. The kitchen is well equipped with a Thermador oven and cooktop, hood, warming drawer, built-in microwave and large side-by-side refrigerator. The home office, currently used as a home gym, sits beside a half bath. Upstairs, a split staircase leads to four bedrooms. Three share a hall bath, while the primary suite includes a sitting room, two walk-in closets, a linen closet, and a bathroom with a corner tub and separate shower. The home provides adequate space for two home offices both enjoying the beautiful views of the rolling hills of the fairway. Cherry Valley Country Club offers optional membership at several levels. Award-winning Blue-Ribbon Montgomery schools. Princeton, located only a few miles away, with its renowned theatre, museums, restaurants and the University, offers endless cultural and social activities. Some pics virtually stgd

11 Tanglewood Ct, Montgomery Twp.

$975,000
3 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053328 MLS
Welcome to this expansive split-level home offering exceptional space, versatility, hospitality and convenience in one of Union County's desirable communities. The main level features an updated kitchen with an open flow to the dining area and formal living room, beautiful hardwood floors and SS appliances w/ kitchen bar. This well maintained home features updated windows that bring in an abundance of natural light. The primary bedroom offers a private full bath and deep closets, while the additional bedrooms feature hardwood flooring beneath the existing rugs.The freshly painted ground level adds incredible flexibility with updated LVP flooring, a second kitchen, half bath, private secondary entrance off of driveway, and walk-out access to the fully fenced yard with expansive patio and outdoor kitchen set up. This level also provides access to a basement bonus room and laundry area, perfect for recreation, guests, office space, or extended living. A true highlight is the oversized 4-car garage with heater(as is) and both front and rear garage doors, offering exceptional space for vehicles, hobbies, equipment, or storage. Enjoy the privacy of the fully fenced yard and all this home has to offer. Ideally located just minutes from Summit Train Station, bus transportation, Route 22, Route 78, Route 24, the Garden State Parkway, and more, providing convenient access to commuting, shopping, dining, and surrounding communities.

336 Summit Rd, Mountainside Boro

$685,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4053322 MLS
Charming & Completely Renovated Hilton Ranch, Move-In Ready + Work-From-Home Insulated, Temperature-Controlled Office Shed! This spacious 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch was completely renovated in 2018 and is flooded with natural light throughout. The open-plan main living floor features hardwood flooring, 3 bedrooms, a full bath, and an open kitchen with quartz counters, center island and stainless-steel appliances flowing seamlessly into the living and dining spaces. Recessed lighting and ceiling fans add style and comfort, and a private deck off the primary bedroom is the perfect spot to unwind. The finished lower-level offers a rec room, laundry room, a bonus room/office space, a second full bath, and access to the attached garage; ideal for work-from-home flexibility or additional living space, while central AC keeps the whole home comfortable year-round. Outside, enjoy a fully fenced-in, landscaped yard with temperature-controlled custom shed, currently used as a year-round WFH office, but easily adaptable to whatever you can imagine. Unbeatable location: nearby jitney which takes you directly to the midtown train and you're just steps to Springfield Ave's restaurants and shops, farmer's market, local favorite--Parkwood Diner, Dehart Park and the Hilton Library. Plus, you're only a mile to NYC-Direct Train and Maplewood Village! Completely move-in ready with low taxes, curb appeal and beautiful renovations throughout --this one checks every box!

34 Ohio St, Maplewood Twp.

$469,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 4053316 MLS
Welcome to maintenance free living in highly sought-after Fox Hills Active Adult 55+ gated community situated in Rockaway Township! This recently Renovated 2 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Condo with a Den offers a fresh updated interior and an easy comfortable lifestyle. The bright and open living and dining areas flow seamlessly to a private balcony, while the updated Kitchen offers ample cabinetry, counter space, and room for casual dining. The spacious Primary Suite features 2 Walk-in-Closets and a private En-Suite Bathroom. A generously sized second Bedroom, Full Bathroom, and versatile Den provide additional space for a home Office, reading room, or hobby area. Ideally located near the clubhouse and community amenities, this unit also includes one assigned Parking Space in the Underground Garage, a private Storage area, and convenient Elevator access. Fox Hills residents enjoy 24 hour gated security and resort style amenities including a 25,000 Sq. Ft. Clubhouse, Indoor and Outdoor Swimming Pools, Hot Tubs, Fitness Center, Tennis & Pickleball Courts, Bocce Ball, Shuffleboard, Billiards, Card and Game rooms, Social Clubs, Jitney service to shopping, a Greenhouse, and Garden plots. Conveniently located minutes from Rockaway Townsquare, Atlantic Health facilities, restaurants, shopping, and major highways. A beautifully renovated home in one of the area's premier Active Adult Communities, move right in and enjoy everything Fox Hills has to offer.

1213 Clinton Ln, Rockaway Twp.

$375,000
2 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053307 MLS
This Hillsborough townhome puts a 2 bedroom, 2.5 bath layout on a private patio, with room to grow. The primary bathroom was updated in August 2026, giving the main suite a current feel. New storm door 2025, HVAC serviced May 2026, Washing Machine 2026, Kitchen and Bedroom windows 2025, Water Heater 2022, New Roof 2022, Dishwasher 2020. A finished basement adds flexible living space, whether that becomes a home office, a media room, or simple extra storage. This home also has a transferrable warranty and security system. The layout keeps bedrooms and living areas practical for everyday use. Community amenities include a pool and tennis courts, giving residents recreation options without leaving the neighborhood. The private patio extends living space outdoors, good for morning coffee or evening downtime. Hillsborough's location adds real value with Duke Farms nearby for those who want open green space and walking trails close to home. Six Mile Run Reservoir Site and Sourland Mountain Preserve offer additional hiking within a short drive. Route 206 keeps daily errands, shopping, and dining within easy reach, and Raritan Valley Line rail access supports commuters heading toward New York or central New Jersey. Several municipal parks round out the area's recreation options beyond the community amenities. For a buyer who wants updated living space, community amenities, and a location that balances commute access with green space, this one is worth a look.

921 Robin Rd, Hillsborough Twp.

$1,399,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 4053306 MLS
This FULLY renovated home is situated on a large, flat, quiet lot just a short walk to everything Livingston has to offer. Every major system and finish has been thoughtfully updated, including NEW HVAC, ELECTRIC, PLUMBING, WATER & SEWER LINE, WINDOWS, INSULATION, ROOF, SIDING, FLOORS, resurfaced driveway, landscaping, and more. The first floor offers a bright, open-concept layout designed for modern living, centered around a stunning chef's kitchen. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and family rooms, creating an ideal space for everyday living and entertaining. An additional, versatile first-floor room offers flexibility as a den or additional bedroom. Additional first floor benefits include a full bath with heated floor, custom mudroom with garage access, pantry, abundant storage, closets with built-in shelving, a storage room, and sliding doors leading to a new paver patio. The newly added second floor primary suite provides a private retreat with an oversized custom closet featuring built-in shelving and drawers, along with a luxurious spa-inspired bathroom. The second floor also includes three additional spacious bedrooms, a separate private office, a beautifully appointed hall bathroom, and a convenient upstairs laundry room with custom cabinets. An oversized, full standing height attic provides exceptional additional storage space. This turnkey home provides a quiet oasis in one of Livingston's most sought after neighborhoods.

14 Maplewood Dr, Livingston Twp.

$3,300,000
6 Beds 6.1 Baths 4053271 MLS
Spectacular custom-built elegant Colonial boasts 7660sf of exquisite luxury across three levels on .92 level acre in the heart of prime Chestnut Hill. The circular drive leads to an impressive entryway with double height marble foyer, curved staircase. A large living room with gas fireplace and handcrafted built-ins with sliding glass doors to rear gardens is open to large chef's kitchen with Wolf 6 burner gas range with griddle and double ovens, and full size SubZero refrigerator adjacent to full size SubZero freezer. Ethereal formal dining room for amazing entertaining through butler's wet bar pantry with wine refrigerator. A true partner's home office, a family room/library, guest bedroom en suite to full bath, powder room, laundry room and mud room access to 3 car garage complete the first level. A rear staircase also leads to second floor with oversized primary bedroom, a sumptuous marble bath with double stall shower and jetted tub, double sink vanity. Additional 3 bedrooms on this floor all with vaulted ceiligns and en suite to full baths. The lower level is a perfect hideaway with gym, bedroom #6 en suite to full bath, recreation room, media room, 2nd office, utilties including 4 zones of gas FA & CAC and tremendous stroage. The stone patio is the gathering space for the home with a large built-in barbecue, gas fireplace and outdoor TV. Set on private, manicured landscaped level grounds, this manse offers a lifestyle like no other.

2 Hobson Drive, Livingston Twp.

$3,000,000
4053255 MLS
Rare and complete Amwell Valley farm package in East Amwell TownshipCombining a historic farmhouse with nearly 95 acres of contiguous qualified farmland in the protected Amwell Valley Agricultural District (VAL).The offering includes: Farmhouse parcel (Class 3A) " Approximately 2 acres featuring a charming historic residence (circa 1700). Ideal as a primary residence, caretaker home, or agricultural headquarters. Block 31, Lot 3 (Class 3B) " Approximately 41.9 acres of open, qualified farmland Block 27, Lot 47 (Class 3B) " Approximately 53.4 acres of open, qualified farmlandTogether, the two large parcels total roughly 95 acres of open agricultural land, both classified as Farm Qualified (3B) under New Jersey's Farmland Assessment Act for substantially reduced property taxes. The combined land assessment remains modest, supporting low annual taxes while preserving the property's agricultural integrity.Located along Rocktown Road in a peaceful, private setting yet convenient to Princeton and major routes, this assemblage offers exceptional versatility for active farming, equestrian use, land preservation, or a private country estate. VAL zoning strongly supports agricultural operations and limited residential development consistent with the township's farmland-protection goals.A unique opportunity to own both a historic farmhouse and extensive protected farmland under single ownership in one of Hunterdon County's most desirable agricultural communities

78 Rocktown Rd, East Amwell Twp.

Start Your Search

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated: