Middletown Real Estate Search

Middletown Properties between $1,500,000 and $2,000,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $1,500,000 and $2,000,000 properties available in Middletown and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Middletown real estate market? Sign up for a  Middletown Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Middletown Properties between $1,500,000 and $2,000,000 for Sale

$1,500,000
4018908 MLS
Presenting a rare opportunity to acquire a renovated, 3,800 SF trophy mixed-use property ideally positioned adjacent to NP train station. Formerly a bank building, this asset was completely reimagined in 2019 with a full-scale renovation, including an expansion of the existing footprint, modernized systems, and high-end finishes. This features an impressive, high-end entryway w/a spacious reception area, anchored by a large reception desk & flanked by 4 well-proportioned private offices creating an immediate, professional first impression. A state-of-the-art conference room further enhances functionality, making the space ideal for client-facing businesses.Upper level offers 4 additional private offices along with a flexible administrative or bullpen-style workspace, allowing for efficient team operations and scalability. Fully finished lower level provides exceptional versatility, offering customizable space to suit a variety of use cases, complemented by a beautifully designed kitchen ideal for staff use or client hospitality .Zoned mixed-use, the property is well-suited for professional, medical, retail, or service-oriented users, as well as investors seeking a premier, turnkey asset in a highly desirable submarket.Strategically located in a transit-oriented setting, the property benefits from consistent foot traffic, strong visibility,& seamless accessibility. 17 dedicated on-site parking spaces further enhances its appeal an increasingly rare amenity in this market.

82 Floral Ave, New Providence Boro

$1,795,000
9 Beds 5.2 Baths 4018888 MLS
Welcome to 17 Three Gables Road, a great opportunity to renovate or build your dream with possibilities of subdividing the property. This home and property are iconic testaments to timeless elegance and grandeur nestled in the heart of Morristown, NJ. This American Shingle-style estate, originally built in 1890, offers an unparalleled opportunity to craft your dream residence with historic charm and modern possibilities. Spanning over 9,000 square feet, this residence boasts nine bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and two half bathrooms, elegantly framed by stately high ceilings and beautiful craftsmanship. Set on over two acres, the property presents a canvas for creating your own private estate. There may also be an opportunity to explore subdivision opportunities while keeping the main residence or building two new homes. A formal dining room, perfect for hosting grand gatherings, and a home office, ideal for today's dynamic work-from-home needs, enhance the appeal. Enjoy the serenity of a spacious porch and private outdoor space, offering a refuge from the bustle of everyday life. With a five-car garage, this property caters to the discerning car enthusiast or offers ample storage. The home's commanding presence and historic allure make it a rare find, promising both a luxurious lifestyle and a sound investment. Seize the opportunity to own a piece of history and transform it into your legacy. Discover the potential of this extraordinary estate today! Home is being sold As Is

17 Three Gables Rd, Morris Twp.

$1,900,000
3 Beds 4.1 Baths 4017830 MLS
A rare opportunity to own a brand new, architecturally striking lakefront home in the highly sought-after Erskine Lakes community of Ringwood. Thoughtfully designed to embrace the natural topography, this custom residence offers three levels of finished living space (approx 3700 sq ft), expansive decking, and stunning lake views from nearly every room. The main living level features a bright, open-concept layout with a designer kitchen, oversized island, dining area, and spacious family room. Walls of glass and sliding doors lead to a full-width deck perfect for entertaining or simply taking in the peaceful surroundings. A primary suite on this level provides convenience and privacy, complete with a spa-like bath and generous closet space. The middle level offers two additional bedrooms and flexible living space, ideal for guests, home office, or recreation, all designed with modern flow and functionality in mind. The walkout lower level is a true standout, featuring exceptional ceiling height specifically designed to accommodate a golf simulator, along with ample space for a media room, gym, or game area. Direct access to outdoor terraces and professionally designed landscaping enhances the indoor-outdoor lifestyle. Enjoy all that Erskine Lake has to offer, including year round social events, beach club, access to beaches, boating, and a vibrant lake community all just under an hour from NYC. To be built- bring your vision and make this exceptional lakefront home your own.

323 Lakeview Ave, Ringwood Boro

$1,988,888
6 Beds 5.1 Baths 4017381 MLS
Rare opportunity! Step into luxury with this to-be-built 6-bedroom, 5.1-bath Modern Transitional Colonial on a quiet cul-de-sac in Mountainside. Spanning 4,984 sq. ft. across three levels, this home offers exceptional craftsmanship and an early-stage opportunity to collaborate with the builder on select finishes, including cabinetry, countertops, and flooring.The main level (1,908 sq. ft.) features an open-concept kitchen and breakfast area flowing into a family room, plus a formal dining room, private home office, powder room, and guest en-suite. Upstairs (1,850 sq. ft.), the primary suite includes a five-fixture spa bath and oversized walk-in dressing room, with three additional bedrooms, two full baths, and a laundry center. The walk-out lower level (1,226 sq. ft.) adds a sixth bedroom, full bath, and large recreation area.Additional highlights include a built-in 1-car oversized garage and double-width driveway. Mountainside offers a streamlined NYC commute via the NJ Transit Midtown Direct train and Route 22 bus, top-rated schools including Deerfield School and Governor Livingston High School, and proximity to Watchung Reservation, Trailside Nature & Science Center, Watchung Stable, major highways, and Newark Liberty International Airport. A rare chance to customize your dream home today! Fall completion. Under construction, property is currently framed, windows to be installed next week-There is no access to interior- you may drive by to see front exterior.

295 Chattin Ct, Mountainside Boro

$1,500,000
4017006 MLS
Prime Investment Opportunity: Turnkey Hospitality & Multi-Phase Development Opportunity!!Rarely does a property offer immediate cash flow along with development potential. Situated on a high-visibility deep lot, this multifaceted site is ideal for the strategic investor or owner-operator looking to diversify their portfolio.The Restaurant: Fully renovated, functioning (QSR) restaurant. * New HVAC, plumbing, electrical systems, framing, insulation, bathrooms, etc. * Contemporary dining room with high-end fixtures and a welcoming atmosphere. * Fully equipped with commercial-grade appliances and optimized for high-volume service.Single-Family Rental: Attached to the restaurant is a single-family home, currently utilized as a rental property.The Future: Conceptual Apartment Development!Maximize the "highest and best use" of this land. Included with the sale are professional conceptual drawings for multi-family residential expansion designed by the township engineer.Concept A: 11-units ,1,236sf per unit over 3 floors (knock down all existing structures)Concept B: 5-units, 1,200sf per unit over 2 floors and keep the existing restaurant but knock down the house Concept C: 3-4 units, 1,500sf per unit over 2 floors and keep the existing restaurant but knock down the houseConcept D: 9-units, 1,000sf per unit over 3 floors (knock down all existing structures)Additional Revenue: Active Truck Parking currently generates auxiliary income by leasing out truck parking spots.

897 Ringwood Ave, Wanaque Boro

$1,795,000
5 Beds 5.1 Baths 4016472 MLS
An elegant white 19th century Federal Style Home just 5 miles from Princeton stands on four acres with sweeping views of bountiful gardens, a picturesque pond and park-like lawns. Just passing by, it is clear that the current owners have been excellent stewards of this historic property. Even though the house was built with large rooms and high ceilings across all three floors, carefully considered expansions by acclaimed local architect Max Hayden have added still more space for entertaining, as well as the possibility of single-level living. French doors flanking the living room fireplace open to a glorious sunroom with a stone floor and a commanding stone fireplace. Off the celebration-sized dining room, the second addition serves as an office or a stunning guest suite. The eat-in kitchen has modern functionality with pro-level appliances and an open sightline into the family room, yet custom cherry cabinetry feels period-appropriate and a walk-in fireplace stands as a reminder of meals simmering all day over a constant flame. All have great closet space, especially the primary suite with a walk-in outside the cheerfully tiled bath. With a full kitchen and a clean white bathroom, the multi-room third floor serves equally well as a guest suite or a spot for all-day play and all-night sleepovers. Even the cupola capped garage beautifully supports the needs of a modern lifestyle with three bays, a workshop and solar panels.

122 Bedens Brook Rd, Montgomery Twp.

$1,790,000
5 Beds 5.1 Baths 4016403 MLS
5,000+ Sq Ft Residence Curved Staircase Private Lower-Level Living Designed for layered living and effortless flow, this expansive residence offers a refined balance of scale, structure, and flexibility. A dramatic double-height foyer introduces a signature curved staircase, creating a striking architectural focal point and a strong sense of arrival.The main level unfolds into generously proportioned living spaces, including formal living and dining rooms, an inviting fmy-room, and an open-concept kitchen with breakfast area. Large windows and French doors bring in abundant natural light while seamlessly connecting interior spaces to the outdoor terrace and landscaped grounds. The second level is thoughtfully arranged with a spacious primary suite and multiple well-sized bedrooms positioned across two distinct wings, offering both privacy and functionality. A secondary staircase enhances everyday circulation and convenience. The fully finished lower level is designed as a private living suite, complete with its own entrance to the backyard, kitchen, bedroom, bathroom, laundry, and direct patio access ideal for living, guests, or flexible use. Additional highlights include a stone exterior fa ade, circular driveway, 3-car garage, and finished attic providing additional usable space.A rare offering that combines architectural presence, open flow, and multi-level living versatility in one exceptional home.

15 Michelle Way, Montville Twp.

$1,995,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 4015906 MLS
Set within Bernardsville's coveted "On The Mountain" enclave, this extraordinary residence is a rare offering steeped in architectural history and timeless charm. Originally the carriage house of famed 19th and 20th century architect George B. Post Sr.'s estate, this expanded and converted 1890s home rests on over 5 private acres, accessed by a long and winding driveway setting the tone for serenity and seclusion. History echoes throughout the home, where original stonework, century-old trees, and plantings create a rich sense of place. It beautifully balances traditional authenticity with modern elegance, offering warmth, character, and charm at every turn. At the heart of the home is a dramatic living room, offering an inviting space for both grand entertaining and quiet reflection. With over 5,000 square feet of living space and following an substantial addition, the home features five bedrooms and five full bathrooms, including a private guest suite. Outdoor living is equally compelling with seasonal views of the Somerset Hills, inground pool, and eight garage spaces for the car enthusiast, a truly rare amenity. Located just minutes from the NJT rail to NYC, shopping the the Somerset Hills Country Club, this one-of-a-kind property rewards its next Owner with a remarkable lifestyle where architectural pedigree, natural beauty, and peaceful living converge. A legacy property and a rare opportunity.

131 Post Kunhardt Rd, Bernardsville Boro

$1,675,000
4009262 MLS
Offered for sale is a high-visibility owner-user commercial property located in the Borough's B-1 General Business District. The building is currently owner-occupied & will be delivered vacant at closing, providing immediate occupancy for an owner-user, operator, or end-user. B-1 zoning permits a wide range of commercial, service, institutional, & cultural uses, including retail, professional & medical offices, personal & business services, hospitality, fitness & recreational facilities, cultural venues, educational uses, & houses of worship, plus customary accessory uses. The flexible zoning supports various business models & adaptive reuse opportunities. Positioned along Route 28 (W Union Ave), a primary commercial corridor, the property offers monument signage & strong visibility to both eastbound & westbound traffic. The location benefits from proximity to downtown Bound Brook, established businesses, & surrounding residential neighborhoods. Convenient access to I-287 & Route 22 provides excellent regional connectivity throughout Somerset County & Central New Jersey. The Bound Brook NJ Transit rail station is nearby, offering direct service to Newark with connections to NYC. Capital improvements completed in 2014 include structural upgrades with metal I-beam construction. The building features a fire alarm system & multi-zone HVAC for operational flexibility. Sale preferred; seller will consider lease or lease with option to purchase.Not offered as an investment property.

454 W Union Ave, Bound Brook Boro

$1,999,000
5 Beds 5.1 Baths 4008290 MLS
One-of-a-kind luxury construction on a dead-end street. Every detail of this high-end home has been thoughtfully designed & upgraded. A grand entry welcomes you to the entry foyer leading to a formal living rm, formal dining rm w/ fireplace & a gorgeous chef's kitchen w/ high-end appliances, custom cabinetry & dining area. The first floor is completed by a family rm w/ fireplace, an office, guest bedroom & 1.5 baths. Upstairs, a beautiful loft area opens to the primary suite-an indulgent retreat featuring a private balcony, 2 walk-in closets & a spa-like bathrm w/ soaking tub & separate shower. Four additional bedrooms, a laundry rm w/ double washer/dryer sets & a full hallway bath complete the second flr. The finished attic provides additional flex space for crafts, gym or studio. The fully finished basement is an entertainer's dream-complete w/ summer kitchen, exquisite bar, rec rm, full bath & second laundry area. Outside, enjoy resort-style living w/ an in-ground pool/hot tub, separate pool lounge/clubhouse w/ bar area, patio paver driveway/walkways, two-car garage w/ full bath & finished loft-perfect for studio space & professionally designed outdoor lighting for the ultimate ambience. Smart home technology, offering Wi-Fi control of security cameras, door locks, doorbell, surround sound & heating/cooling system. A sprinkler system & meticulously landscaped grounds complete this truly exceptional home. A rare opportunity to own a show-stopping masterpiece!

45 Dietrich Ln, North Haledon Boro

$1,850,000
4006167 MLS
An exceptional 40-acre offering in the heart of Hunterdon County, this property presents a rare opportunity to acquire a substantial tract of land with extraordinary frontage and long-term potential. Positioned at the southeast corner of Route 31 and Valley Crest Road, the site offers approximately 1,769 feet of frontage along Route 31 and an additional 910 feet along Valley Crest Road, providing excellent visibility and access along a major north-south corridor. The land features generally level to gently rising topography, suitable for a variety of future uses. Approximately 26 acres are in productive agricultural use, complemented by 14 acres of wooded and undeveloped land that enhance privacy and natural character. The property is farmland assessed, offering favorable carrying costs while in agricultural use. Zoned ROM-1 (Research, Office & Manufacturing), the parcel permits a wide range of uses, including research and laboratory facilities, professional offices, conference centers, light manufacturing, municipal uses, and continued agricultural operations. Located within the Highlands Planning Area "Existing Community Zone," the property offers proximity to regional employment centers while preserving the pastoral character Hunterdon County is known for. Whether envisioned as a long-term investment, build-to-suit opportunity, or continuation of its agricultural legacy, this offering combines scale, frontage, zoning flexibility, and access.

65 Valley Crest Rd, Clinton Twp.

$1,950,000
4 Beds 3.1 Baths 3988419 MLS
Centerline Farm has been home to the equestrian elite for many years and offers a full equestrian facility including housing for farm help. Thoughtful improvements have been made and can accommodate most equestrian disciplines. The main barn features 21 box stalls w/automatic waterers (public water), heated, spacious center aisle, lounge w/powder room, office and a refurbished 2 bedroom apartment. Hay loft, grooming stalls, wash stall with hot/cold water inside & out.The indoor riding arena features LED lighting, insulated roof w/snow eagles, eight+ sliding window/doors,sunbelt providing a light and bright arena, kickwall and seating areas. There is a regulation size dressage court as well as a jumper arena, both of which are fenced.Conveniently located outside the barn are 10 all weather turnout paddocks which connect to a large grass field providing choices for turnout. The facility has it own entrance. Located to the far side of the property is the main house with its own private driveway. A charming custom home with updated kitchen, hardwood floors, fireplace, full basement and two car garage. Beautiful views of the stable complex from the FIRST floor primary suite. There are 3 bedrooms and a full bath on the second floor. The inground pool and hot tub are sold as-is. This prime location provides access to the top veterinarians in the country and is also minutes away to the United States Equestrian Team, hunter paces, Christie Hoffman Park and Tewksbury Trails.

245 Old Turnpike, Tewksbury Twp.

Start Your Search

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated: