Middletown Real Estate Search

Middletown Single Family Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for single family properties available in Middletown and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Middletown real estate market? Sign up for a  Middletown Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Middletown Single Family Homes for Sale

$3,300,000
6 Beds 6.1 Baths 4053271 MLS
Spectacular custom-built elegant Colonial boasts 7660sf of exquisite luxury across three levels on .92 level acre in the heart of prime Chestnut Hill. The circular drive leads to an impressive entryway with double height marble foyer, curved staircase. A large living room with gas fireplace and handcrafted built-ins with sliding glass doors to rear gardens is open to large chef's kitchen with Wolf 6 burner gas range with griddle and double ovens, and full size SubZero refrigerator adjacent to full size SubZero freezer. Ethereal formal dining room for amazing entertaining through butler's wet bar pantry with wine refrigerator. A true partner's home office, a family room/library, guest bedroom en suite to full bath, powder room, laundry room and mud room access to 3 car garage complete the first level. A rear staircase also leads to second floor with oversized primary bedroom, a sumptuous marble bath with double stall shower and jetted tub, double sink vanity. Additional 3 bedrooms on this floor all with vaulted ceiligns and en suite to full baths. The lower level is a perfect hideaway with gym, bedroom #6 en suite to full bath, recreation room, media room, 2nd office, utilties including 4 zones of gas FA & CAC and tremendous stroage. The stone patio is the gathering space for the home with a large built-in barbecue, gas fireplace and outdoor TV. Set on private, manicured landscaped level grounds, this manse offers a lifestyle like no other.

2 Hobson Drive, Livingston Twp.

$1,825,000
7 Beds 6.1 Baths 4053224 MLS
Magnificent & truly one-of-a-kind, this exceptional home rests on over 1/2 acre in the sought after Montrose section of South Orange. From its beautiful curb appeal to its striking interior, the home makes an unforgettable first impression. Step inside, and the spectacular foyer immediately sets the tone for the extraordinary spaces that await. Throughout the home, high & beamed ceilings, beautifully crafted woodwork, stunning leaded windows and distinctive architectural columns showcase its timeless character. The 2022 gourmet kitchen is designed to impress, while the striking family room w/radiant floor heating (2019) captivates w/dramatic cathedral beamed ceiling, creating a spectacular space for both everyday living & entertaining. The second floor offers 4 spacious bedrooms & 3 full bathrooms, including a primary suite, large walk-in dressing closet & private bathroom. 2 additional bedrooms feature en suite bathrooms, providing comfort & privacy. The third floor offers 3 additional spacious bedrooms, a full bathroom & attic storage, providing exceptional flexibility & ample space or a home office. The outdoor spaces are equally impressive, featuring a spacious patio w/gas stone fireplace located right off the inviting sun room, plus an open porch overlooking the private backyard. The 3 car garage offers ample parking & storage, with exciting potential for the loft above. Less than 1/2 mile to the Mountain Station for NYC train.

138 Irving Ave, South Orange Village Twp.

$1,895,000
5 Beds 4.1 Baths 4053219 MLS
SPRAWLING 5-BED STORYBOOK COLONIAL NESTLED ON 1.5 PRIVATE ACRES IN PICTURESQUE WARREN NEIGHBORHOOD. Seamless blend of timeless charm & modern amenities, starting w/ long driveway winding over quaint bridge. Elegant 2-story Foyer flows into stunning Living Room w/ soaring conical ceiling & double-height Windows. Formal Dining Room w/ tray ceiling has double-sided gas fireplace that also adds warmth & ambiance to window-filled Breakfast Room. Gourmet Chef's Kitchen has expansive Center Island w/ Seating, cherry cabinetry, Pantry sized for Costco hauls. Overlooks spectacular 2-Story Family Room w/ striking brick wood-burning FP flanked by 2 sets of French doors w/ extra-tall transoms that open to composite wood Deck. Great indoor/outdoor flow! Skylights invite even more natural light, creating cozy & sun-filled space to gather or lounge. 1st Level also has Laundry Room, Bedroom/Office w/ adjacent Full Bath. Upstairs 2 generous bedrooms share Jack & Jill Full Bath. 3rd Bedroom has private En-Suite. Luxurious Primary Suite has 2 walk-in Custom Closets & spacious En-suite Bath w/ deep tub set in windowed nook. Ample Storage! Lower Level designed for entertaining & flexibility boasts massive Media Room w/ surround-sound speakers & fully equipped wet bar, Poker/Game Room & large Rec Room w/ lovely LVP flooring. Multiple staircases w/ direct access to 3-car Garage & lush, private Backyard w/ 5-hole putting green & ample room for garden or future pool. Don't miss 16 Trinity Place!

16 Trinity Pl, Warren Twp.

$1,550,000
4 Beds 3.1 Baths 4053215 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully 2020 reconstructed 4 BR, 3.1 BA home, thoughtfully designed with exceptional craftsmanship and modern comfort throughout. Featuring Andersen windows, 9 FT ceilings on first floor, custom trim work and coffered ceilings. This move-in-ready residence offers the perfect blend of style and functionality. The heart of the home is the stunning open-concept kitchen, featuring a spacious center island, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a convenient wet bar, all flowing seamlessly into the inviting living room and family room with a gas fireplace. A first-floor office, mudroom, and powder room add everyday convenience and versatility. Upstairs offers a luxurious primary suite, a spa-like bath and generous walk-in closet, accompanied by three additional bedrooms and main bath. The finished lower level expands the living space with a rec room and full bath, creating a flexible area ideal for recreation, guests, a home gym, or office. Outdoor living is equally impressive, with a patio featuring a motorized retractable awning and a fully fenced yard with a 6-foot vinyl privacy fence. Additional highlights include a new furnace installed in 2026, whole-house generator, EV charger in the garage, and fresh interior paint. Ideally located close to Oakwood Park, shopping, and NYC transportation, this exceptional home is truly move-in ready and offers the space, quality, and convenience today's buyers are seeking.

97 Commonwealth Ave, New Providence Boro

$699,000
3 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053202 MLS
Luxury living meets resort-style entertaining at 2623 Frederick Terrace! This exceptional Union residence offers sophisticated interiors, thoughtful upgrades & a spectacular private backyard oasis. The open-concept main level features soaring ceilings, recessed lighting, a gas fireplace with built-ins & a stunning kitchen with center island, abundant storage, tile flooring & premium GE Monogram appliances. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite features a vaulted ceiling, oversized windows, recessed lighting & backyard views, plus a spa-like bath with skylight, stand-up shower & separate Jacuzzi tub. A WIC with custom built-ins & attic access completes the suite. The 2nd & 3rd bedrooms each offer natural light & double-door closets, with a full guest bath completing the level. The finished basement includes central vac, tankless Navien, serviced boiler, laundry, 200-amp service + additional panel & Generac whole-house generator connected to natural gas. The backyard is a true retreat with a heated in-ground pool, filtered by an EcoSmarte copper-based system, waterfall, connected spa, pergola, patio, outdoor kitchen with Weber grill, cooler & mini fridge, vegetable garden, mud kitchen & irrigation. 1-car garage, paver driveway, 2 garage refrigerators, underground drainage & main sewer line replaced approx. 8 years ago. Convenient to Millburn Train Station & a nearby bus stop with direct service to NY Port Authority. A rare blend of luxury, comfort & effortless entertaining.

2623 Frederick Ter, Union Twp.

$1,050,000
5 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053198 MLS
A truly special Victorian in the heart of Maplewood's beloved, close-knit College Hill neighborhood, this move-in ready home offers 5 bedrooms, 2.1 bathrooms and more than 125 years of history, warmth, and genuine character. Built in 1898 on what was once a cherry farm, this remarkable home is filled with sweet details rarely found today. A wonderful wrap-around front porch welcomes you into gracious interiors with beautiful original woodwork, leaded-glass windows, pocket doors, and timeless architectural craftsmanship throughout. Generous first floor living and entertaining spaces flow into an updated kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and modernized half-bath. A spacious second floor features 4 bedrooms; one with an adjoining enclosed "sleeping porch, perfect for work or play; and a large full hall bath. The third floor has a lovely bedroom escape, additional bonus/office space, and another full bath, creating the potential for a large primary suite or work-from-home oasis. This very well maintained and updated home has plenty of additional storage areas on the 3rd floor and basement as well as a lush and private backyard space. Ideally located with convenient access to Maplewood Village, restaurants, shops, parks and NYC transportation. A rare opportunity to own an enduring piece of Maplewood history with the space, character, and warmth that make definitive homes so unforgettable.

39 Oberlin St, Maplewood Twp.

$2,699,900
5 Beds 4.2 Baths 4053193 MLS
EXCEPTIONAL NEW CONSTRUCTION in highly sought-after North Caldwell! This stunning Hamptons-style luxury home offers 5 BRs, 4 full & 2 half BAs, a 3-car garage & sophisticated designer finishes throughout. Approximately 20 miles from NYC, enjoy suburban luxury & commuter convenience, close to top-rated schools, restaurants, parks, recreation, shopping & major highways. Timeless Hardie siding welcomes you into a dramatic TWO-STORY ENTRY FOYER with soaring ceilings, setting the tone for the impressive, light-filled interior. The thoughtfully designed open-concept floor plan features a 1st-floor BR w/full BA, dedicated home office, formal LR & DR, and expansive family room ideal for everyday living & entertaining. The showstopping chef's kitchen features top-tier appliances, custom cabinetry & generous prep and entertaining space. A beautifully appointed BUTLER'S PANTRY flows seamlessly from the kitchen to the formal dining room, creating the perfect setup for hosting & entertaining. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite is a true retreat featuring a fireplace, wet bar, huge walk-in closet & spa-like primary BA with dual vanities & soaking tub. Generously sized BRs, high ceilings, luxury finishes & incredible living spaces throughout. A rare opportunity to own brand-new luxury construction in one of North Caldwell's most desirable communities, offering exceptional design, space, functionality & proximity to NYC!

38 Brookside Ter, North Caldwell Boro

$660,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 4053180 MLS
Are you looking for the perfect home in an unbeatable location? This charming residence offers the ideal combination of comfort, convenience, and low-maintenance living. Enjoy the luxury of being just a short walk to the train, bus, elementary school, middle school, and high school making commuting and everyday life incredibly convenient. A private, inviting front porch framed by beautiful landscaping welcomes you home and provides the perfect place to relax w/your morning coffee or unwind at the end of the day. Step inside to discover a welcoming 1st floor featuring soaring ceilings, a spacious living room, a formal dining room, and an eat-in kitchen, creating the perfect setting for both everyday living & entertaining. The 2nd level offers two generously sized bedrooms, a separate dressing room, and a full bath. The 3rd floor provides even more versatile living space w/ a private bedroom and a cozy sitting area.Outside, you'll enjoy a private backyard with a shed & a fenced yard that's perfect for relaxing or entertaining while requiring very little maintenance. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, looking to downsize, or simply searching for an alternative to renting or condo living, this home offers the privacy, space, and lifestyle of single-family ownership in one of the area's most desirable and walkable locations. Chimney & liner 2023, HWH 2025, Central Air 2025, Furnace 2024 and roof only 12 years old, Dishwasher & Refrigerator 2024, Stove 7/2026! Don't miss!

714 North Ave West, Westfield Town

$785,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 4053176 MLS
Welcome to 106 Virginia Street, where the renovation is truly a showstopper! Step inside to gleaming new hardwood floors, designer lighting, and exceptional craftsmanship throughout. The showpiece kitchen features a full suite of GE appliances, including a double wall oven with convection/microwave combo, custom cabinetry, striking lighting, and sleek modern fixtures perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A convenient first-floor bedroom adds flexibility, while two beautifully renovated, spa-inspired bathrooms elevate everyday living. The oversized upstairs bath also offers an easy opportunity to create a private primary en-suite by adding a doorway and slightly resizing the vanity, while preserving hallway access to the second upstairs bedroom. Approved plans include a future primary suite over the garage. Major systems have been thoughtfully updated, including a brand-new roof, HVAC, thermostats, and windows. The finished basement offers flexible space for a family room, gym, recreation room, or home office. Ideally located just 1 minute from the Garden State Parkway and approximately 5 minutes from bustling downtown Westfield, with its exceptional restaurants, boutique shopping, and vibrant community. Convenient NYC transportation adds to the appeal. A fantastic alternative to purchasing a condo or townhome, this home offers the space, privacy, and flexibility of a single-family home without sacrificing convenience.

106 Virginia St, Westfield Town

$929,000
4 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053168 MLS
Welcome to this well-maintained 4-bedroom home in the desirable Butterworth Farms neighborhood of Morris Township. Offering approximately 2,550 square feet, the home features generously sized rooms, an open floor plan, and comfortable living spaces designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The two-story foyer opens to a light-filled interior with high ceilings and a natural flow between the main living areas. The kitchen features granite countertops, ample cabinetry, and easy access to the surrounding living and dining spaces. Thoughtful details and hardwood floors throughout the home add to its timeless appeal, including updated molding, a new stair runner, fresh interior paint, and newer siding. The flexible finished lower level offers additional space for recreation, hobbies, a home office, along with an additional bathroom. Mature trees surround the property, creating picturesque views and a private, peaceful setting. A large deck extends the living space outdoors and overlooks the fully fenced backyard, providing plenty of room for outdoor dining, recreation, and relaxation. An oversized two-car garage provides ample storage and everyday convenience. Ideally located near Butterworth Park and just minutes from Morristown's acclaimed dining, shopping, parks, and cultural attractions, with convenient access to major commuter routes, this home offers a wonderful balance of space, comfort, privacy, and location.

49 Raynor Rd, Morris Twp.

$829,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 4053167 MLS
This is the one! Impressive & move-in ready doesn't begin to describe this spectacular home, completely updated & renovated in 2024. An inviting, bright & airy open floor plan welcomes you throughout the main living areas. Sunlight pours in, creating a warm & welcoming atmosphere. A wood-burning fireplace anchors the living room, which flows seamlessly into the dining room & chef's kitchen. The kitchen features modern appliances, ample counter space, & a spacious island truly a cook's dream & perfect for entertaining. The kitchen opens directly to an incredible paver patio, creating an effortless indoor-outdoor flow. Four generously sized bedrooms offer plenty of space, including a primary suite w/ a walk-in closet & a second bedroom with its own walk-in closet. Both full bathrooms have been completely updated & are beautifully maintained. An additional first-floor room offers endless flexibility as a home office, playroom, family room, or whatever suits your needs. The finished basement features a laundry room & gym, with ample space to create a recreation room. A spacious two-car garage provides additional convenience. Security system and generator are included. The crown jewel is the nearly one-acre, private, meticulously manicured oasis this home is nestled on. Fully fenced and complete with a paver patio & pergola, it's perfect for relaxing or entertaining outdoors. All you need to do is unpack & move right in! Located in prestigious Mountain Lakes High School district.

6 Estler Ln, Boonton Twp.

$1,029,000
6 Beds 3 Baths 4053156 MLS
SPACIOUS SCOTCH PLAINS 6-BED W/ TRUE GUEST SUITE W/ SEPARATE ENTRANCE, FULL KITCHEN & BATH! Woodsy 1-acre tucked on peaceful cul-de-sac near Ash Brook Golf Course & minutes from everything! Incredibly flexible floorplan boasting 2 above-grade, 2000-sqft & fully equipped levels. First Level Living Room w/ woodburning FP & built-in bookshelves flows into Dining Room w/ large Windows. Adjacent Sunroom is perfect for sprawling out to watch tv or read. Eat-In Kitchen is updated w/ s/s appliances & granite countertops. 4 Bdrms are tucked on far side of Main Level for amazing privacy. Sun-filled Primary offers Cedar Closet, Walk-in Closet & nicely finished En-Suite Bath w/ tile-lined Shower. 3 more Bdrms w/ multiple Windows & good-sized Closets share Full Hall Bath w/ double vanity, tub/shower & water closet. Lower Level Guest Suite has convenient separate entrance. Large Eat-In Kitchen is bright & cheerful w/ access to Backyard Paver Patio. Open to light-filled Family Room w/ modern wood-look tile flooring, 2 sets of double Windows. 2 large Bdrms share Full Hall Bath w/ 2 Linen Closets. Excellent Storage throughout. Separate, extra-deep 3-car Garage w/ 600-sqft Attic. Huge, bucolic, private property offers In-ground Pool, raised garden beds, charming Gazebo & plenty of space to play. New roof (2023), boiler (2026), updated electrical (2026) & more. Hard-to-find balance of acreage & convenient location w/ amazing floorplan. Don?t miss 2 Orchard Drive!

2 Orchard Dr, Scotch Plains Twp.

$675,000
4 Beds 2.1 Baths 4053153 MLS
CONTRACTOR, HOBBYIST & OUTDOOR PARADISE: Tucked off the road on 3.09 private wooded acres, this Hillsborough retreat combines hard-to-find acreage & incredible workshop capability w/ total structural peace of mind. All major capital improvements are ALREADY DONE: Brand-new GAF Architectural Roof w/ transferable 50-year warranty (2026), Pre-Inspected & Passed Septic (2026), Passed Well Certification, Serviced HVAC, New Garage Doors/Openers (2026), Plus, a NATURAL GAS LINE IS STUBBED AT THE HOUSE, ready for an easy meter set & future connection!An absolute dream for hobbyists, contractors, or car enthusiasts, features 3.5-car total garage capacity oversized 2-car attached w/ loft storage + detached 1.5-car powered workshop. The private driveway offers an expanded parking area w/ space for RVs, campers, boats, or work vehicles. The walk-out lower level adds a secondary workshop w/ industrial shelving & commercial stainless-steel triple-basin utility sink.Outside, host on approx. 1,000 sq. ft. of multi-level decking & covered patio w/ ceiling fan, oversized propane grill & prep station. Inside, experience brand-new modern lighting throughout, hardwood floors, cozy family room w/ wood fireplace & new LVP, 2-zone A/C, 3-zone heat, 200-amp electric, and full generator transfer setup w/ portable generator included. Just 15 mins to downtown Hillsborough & Flemington, adjacent to South Branch Wildlife Management Area!

200 Hockenbury Rd, Hillsborough Twp.

Start Your Search

The data displayed relating to real estate for sale comes in part from the IDX Program of Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. Real estate listings held by other brokerage firms are marked as IDX Listing.
The information being provided is for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Copyright 2026 Garden State Multiple Listing Service, L.L.C. All rights reserved.

Updated: