October 22, 2026
By Courtney Orlando, REALTOR® | Courtney Orlando Group | Compass Real Estate
If you have been following national real estate headlines, you might assume buyers now have the upper hand everywhere. But here in New Jersey, the picture is more complicated—and understanding that difference matters when you are deciding whether to buy, sell, or plan your next move.
According to Redfin’s September 2026 analysis, sellers outnumbered buyers nationally by approximately 63%, and 41 of the 50 major metropolitan areas studied qualified as buyer’s markets. Yet the Newark metro remained a seller’s market, with approximately 18.5% fewer sellers than buyers. The New Brunswick market was nearly evenly balanced, according to the figures reported by Patch.
These are regional measurements, not a verdict on every New Jersey neighborhood. Redfin’s estimates are seasonally adjusted and subject to revision. Still, they illustrate why national headlines cannot tell you what to expect from an individual home sale.
“Real estate decisions need to start with what is happening around your home,” says Courtney Orlando, team leader of the Courtney Orlando Group at Compass Real Estate. “The national conversation gives us context. The competing listings, recent sales, and buyer response in your neighborhood help us build your strategy.”
For homeowners and buyers throughout Central and Northern New Jersey, that distinction is especially useful. A home in Bridgewater may face different competition than a property in Morristown, Readington, or Montclair. Even within the same town, price range, condition, location, and layout can change the experience.
For sellers, preparation and pricing still matter
A regional seller’s advantage does not mean every home will attract multiple offers or sell above asking price. Buyers still compare value carefully, and an ambitious price needs support from the market.
Before listing, homeowners should understand which properties buyers will compare with theirs, what similar homes actually sold for, and how much competition is currently available. Presentation matters, too—but preparing a home does not automatically mean undertaking an expensive renovation.
“Sometimes the most valuable preparation is knowing what you do not need to spend money on,” Courtney explains. “We want to help homeowners focus on the improvements that make sense for their property, their timeline, and their likely buyer.”
At the Courtney Orlando Group | Compass Real Estate, that process begins with a personalized assessment. The team helps sellers evaluate pricing, preparation, photography, marketing, and timing as parts of one coordinated plan.
Pairing local guidance with Compass’s marketing resources and agent network helps the team present each property thoughtfully and connect with prospective buyers and their agents.
For buyers, opportunity depends on the property
A national shift toward buyers should not lead you to assume every New Jersey seller will accept a substantial discount. But it is equally unhelpful to assume that every home requires an aggressive offer.
The better question is: What does this particular property’s position in the market tell us?
A listing with recent price reductions, substantial competition, or a longer marketing period may offer room for discussion. Another home may attract immediate interest because its price, condition, and location align with what buyers want.
Negotiation also extends beyond the purchase price. Depending on the circumstances, closing dates, repairs, and seller credits may become part of the conversation.
“A good offer should reflect both the market and your comfort level,” Courtney says. “Our role is to help you understand the home’s value, recognize where there may be flexibility, and make a decision you can feel comfortable living with.”
The Courtney Orlando Group helps buyers compare properties, review comparable sales, and develop an offer strategy suited to their goals.
Selling here and moving elsewhere? Compare both markets.
For homeowners considering a move out of New Jersey, differences between markets deserve attention.
Selling in an area where supply remains limited and purchasing somewhere with more available homes could create useful options. Whether that translates into a better move depends on the actual sale proceeds, purchase price, financing, taxes, insurance, and moving costs.
Before making a decision, it helps to evaluate both sides together.
Through Compass’s agent network, the Courtney Orlando Group can help coordinate with a real estate professional in your destination market, so your sale and purchase plans work toward the same goal.
“When someone is relocating, we want to understand the whole move,” Courtney says. “Where are you going, what will your next home cost, and how can we coordinate the timing? Those answers matter just as much as the price of the home you are selling.”
Start with a plan for your home
Whether you are ready to move or simply exploring the possibilities, a personalized conversation can help you understand your options.
The Courtney Orlando Group | Compass Real Estate serves buyers and sellers throughout Central and Northern New Jersey, including communities across Somerset, Morris, Hunterdon, Essex, and Middlesex counties.
Visit CourtneyOrlandoGroup.com to connect with the team, request a personalized home value review at NewJerseyHomeValue.com, or explore homes at AllNewJerseyListings.com.
Your next move starts with understanding your market—and having a team ready to help you navigate it.
Courtney Orlando
REALTOR®/Sales Associate & Team Leader
Compass Real Estate | Courtney Orlando Group
M: 732.921.1825 | O: 973.315.8180
Courtney@CourtneyOrlandoGroup.com